Man Utd Vs Fiorentina: Player Ratings & Analysis

Oct 23, 2025 by Jhon Lennon 49 views

Let's dive straight into the player ratings from the Man Utd vs Fiorentina clash! It's always interesting to dissect how each player performed, especially in pre-season friendlies where managers are experimenting with lineups and formations. These games offer a glimpse into what we might expect from the team in the upcoming season. Analyzing player ratings helps us understand who's looking sharp, who might need more time to gel with the squad, and which tactical approaches seem promising. So, buckle up as we break down the individual performances and provide a comprehensive analysis of the match.

Manchester United Player Ratings

Alright, Man Utd fans, let's get into the nitty-gritty of each player's performance! We'll scrutinize their contributions, focusing on key aspects like passing accuracy, defensive solidity, attacking threat, and overall impact on the game. Remember, pre-season is all about building fitness and fine-tuning strategies, so these ratings are more about individual displays and potential than definitive judgments.

Goalkeeper

Dean Henderson: Henderson had a relatively quiet night but showed composure when called upon. His distribution was crisp, and he commanded his area well. A solid performance, earning him a 7/10. He made a couple of decent saves and looked confident in goal, which is exactly what you want to see from a keeper vying for the starting spot. His ability to play out from the back was also noticeable, fitting into the modern game's demands for goalkeepers.

Defenders

Aaron Wan-Bissaka: Wan-Bissaka was his usual solid self defensively, winning his tackles and preventing Fiorentina's wingers from causing too much trouble. However, his attacking output remains an area for improvement. A 6.5/10. While defensively sound, his contribution in the final third was limited, highlighting the need for him to develop his crossing and attacking positioning.
Harry Maguire: Maguire looked assured at the back, organizing the defense and making crucial interceptions. His passing was accurate, and he posed a threat from set-pieces. A 7.5/10 for the captain. He demonstrated leadership qualities and a calming presence on the field, crucial for a team aiming for silverware. His aerial prowess was also evident, winning several headers in both defensive and offensive situations.
Victor Lindelof: Lindelof partnered Maguire well, displaying good communication and composure. He made a few important blocks and clearances. A 7/10. He complemented Maguire's strengths, creating a solid defensive partnership. His ability to read the game and anticipate danger was commendable, contributing to a relatively comfortable night for the defense.
Luke Shaw: Shaw continued his impressive form, providing width and energy down the left flank. His crossing was dangerous, and he contributed defensively. An 8/10. He was a constant threat going forward, delivering quality crosses into the box and linking up well with the attackers. His defensive work rate was also impressive, tracking back to support the defense and making crucial tackles.

Midfielders

Scott McTominay: McTominay provided steel and energy in midfield, breaking up play and winning tackles. His passing was efficient, and he supported the attack when possible. A 6.5/10. He played a crucial role in shielding the defense and disrupting Fiorentina's attacks. His work rate and commitment were evident, contributing to the team's overall defensive stability.
Paul Pogba: Pogba showed glimpses of his brilliance, dictating the tempo and creating chances with his passing range. However, he wasn't always consistent. A 7/10. His vision and creativity were on display, unlocking the Fiorentina defense with his incisive passes. However, he needs to maintain this level of performance consistently throughout the game.
Bruno Fernandes: Fernandes was lively and creative, pulling the strings in the attacking midfield role. He created several scoring opportunities and looked sharp. An 8.5/10. His energy and creativity were infectious, driving the team forward and creating numerous chances. His link-up play with the attackers was excellent, and he posed a constant threat to the Fiorentina defense.

Forwards

Mason Greenwood: Greenwood was a constant threat, using his pace and dribbling skills to trouble the Fiorentina defense. He scored a well-taken goal. An 8/10. His movement and finishing were sharp, demonstrating his potential to become a world-class striker. He stretched the Fiorentina defense with his pace and created space for his teammates.
Anthony Martial: Martial led the line and showed glimpses of his quality, linking up well with the midfield and creating chances. However, he could have been more clinical in front of goal. A 7/10. His hold-up play and link-up play were good, but he needs to improve his finishing to become a more consistent goalscorer. He needs to be more decisive in front of goal.
Marcus Rashford: Rashford was lively and energetic, running at the Fiorentina defense and creating opportunities. He didn't manage to get on the scoresheet but contributed to the overall attacking threat. A 7.5/10. His pace and trickery caused problems for the Fiorentina defenders, and he created several openings for his teammates. He needs to improve his decision-making in the final third to become even more effective.

Fiorentina Player Ratings

Now, let's shift our focus to the Fiorentina side. It's equally important to analyze their performance, identifying their strengths and weaknesses, and understanding how they approached the game against a strong opponent like Man Utd. We'll assess their key players and highlight those who stood out or struggled during the match.

Goalkeeper

Pietro Terracciano: Terracciano made a few decent saves but was ultimately beaten by Greenwood's strike. His distribution was generally good. A 6/10. He showed glimpses of his shot-stopping ability but was ultimately unable to keep a clean sheet. His command of his area was also tested by the Man Utd attack.

Defenders

Lorenzo Venuti: Venuti struggled to contain Rashford's pace and trickery, finding it difficult to cope with the Man Utd attack. A 5.5/10. He was often caught out of position and struggled to win his tackles. He needs to improve his defensive awareness and positioning.
German Pezzella: Pezzella tried to organize the defense but was often left exposed by the Man Utd attack. He made a few important interceptions but couldn't prevent Greenwood from scoring. A 6/10. He showed leadership qualities but was ultimately unable to prevent Man Utd from creating numerous scoring opportunities.
Igor Julio: Julio partnered Pezzella in central defense and had a mixed performance. He made some good tackles but also made a few errors in possession. A 5.5/10. His decision-making needs to improve, and he needs to be more consistent in his performance.
Cristiano Biraghi: Biraghi provided width down the left flank but struggled to contain Wan-Bissaka's defensive solidity. A 6/10. His crossing was inconsistent, and he didn't create many clear-cut chances for his teammates.

Midfielders

Gaetano Castrovilli: Castrovilli showed glimpses of his quality in midfield, creating a few chances with his passing range. However, he wasn't always consistent. A 6.5/10. He needs to impose himself more on the game and dictate the tempo more effectively.
Sofyan Amrabat: Amrabat provided steel and energy in midfield, breaking up play and winning tackles. However, his passing was sometimes erratic. A 6/10. He needs to improve his distribution and become more accurate with his passes.
Giacomo Bonaventura: Bonaventura was lively and creative, trying to create opportunities in the attacking midfield role. However, he struggled to make a significant impact on the game. A 6/10. He needs to be more clinical in the final third and create more clear-cut chances.

Forwards

Jose Callejon: Callejon struggled to get into the game, finding it difficult to create chances against the Man Utd defense. A 5.5/10. He needs to be more proactive and find ways to get involved in the game more effectively.
Dusan Vlahovic: Vlahovic led the line for Fiorentina but was isolated for much of the game. He didn't have many clear-cut chances. A 6/10. He needs better service from his teammates and needs to improve his movement off the ball.
Riccardo Saponara: Saponara was lively and energetic, running at the Man Utd defense and trying to create opportunities. However, he didn't manage to make a significant impact on the game. A 6/10. He needs to be more decisive in the final third and improve his finishing.

Key Takeaways

Manchester United looked sharp in attack, with Greenwood, Fernandes, and Rashford all impressing. The defense also looked solid, with Maguire and Lindelof forming a good partnership. Fiorentina struggled to contain the Man Utd attack and lacked creativity in midfield. Pre-season friendlies are crucial for ironing out these kinks and experimenting with different strategies before the competitive season begins.

Overall, this match provided valuable insights into both teams' preparations for the upcoming season. Man Utd fans have reason to be optimistic about their team's attacking potential, while Fiorentina will need to address their defensive vulnerabilities and find more creativity in midfield. Keep an eye on these teams as the season approaches – it's going to be an exciting one!