BRZ Vs. FR-S Vs. GT86: Side-by-Side Comparison

The BRZ, FR-S, and GT86 – these three sports cars have been captivating enthusiasts for over a decade. Born from a joint venture between Subaru and Toyota, these cars offer a unique blend of affordability, engaging handling, and a fun-to-drive experience. But with three names and subtle differences, it's easy to get confused. What exactly sets them apart? Which one is right for you? Let's dive into a detailed, side-by-side comparison to clear up the confusion and help you make the best choice.

A Shared Foundation: The Heart of the Trio

At their core, the BRZ, FR-S (later renamed the 86), and GT86 are fundamentally the same car. They share the same platform, engine, transmission, and overall design. This means you get the same responsive chassis, the same eager-to-revving 2.0-liter boxer engine, and the same rear-wheel-drive thrills regardless of which badge is on the hood.

The engine, a naturally aspirated 2.0-liter horizontally opposed four-cylinder, is the heart and soul of these cars. Its unique boxer configuration contributes to a low center of gravity, enhancing handling and stability. While the horsepower figures – initially 200 hp and later slightly increased in the updated models – might not seem overwhelming on paper, it’s the way this power is delivered that makes these cars so enjoyable. The engine loves to be revved, and the linear power delivery encourages drivers to explore the upper reaches of the RPM range. This makes for an incredibly engaging driving experience, especially on twisty roads.

Both manual and automatic transmissions were offered, with the manual being the preferred choice for enthusiasts. The short throws and precise feel of the manual gearbox perfectly complement the engine's character, providing a direct and involving connection between the driver and the car. The automatic, while not as engaging, still offers a respectable driving experience and can be a good option for those who prefer the convenience of an automatic transmission. The chassis is where these cars truly shine. The combination of a lightweight body, a low center of gravity, and a well-tuned suspension results in exceptional handling. These cars are incredibly responsive and communicative, allowing drivers to feel confident and in control, even when pushing the limits. The steering is precise and well-weighted, providing excellent feedback and making it easy to place the car exactly where you want it on the road.

Decoding the Differences: Badges, Styling, and Features

So, if they're essentially the same car underneath, what are the actual differences between the BRZ, FR-S, and GT86? The distinctions primarily come down to styling, features, and marketing. Let's break it down:

• Styling: While the overall silhouette remains consistent across all three models, there are subtle differences in the front and rear fascias, headlights, taillights, and wheel designs. These styling tweaks were primarily intended to align with each brand's design language and appeal to their respective target audiences. For example, the Subaru BRZ typically features a more understated and refined look, while the Scion FR-S (and later the Toyota 86) often sported a more aggressive and sporty appearance. These differences are subtle, but they contribute to a distinct visual identity for each model.
• Features and Trim Levels: Depending on the model year and trim level, there could be slight variations in the features offered. This could include differences in the standard equipment, such as infotainment systems, interior trim, and available options. However, these differences were generally minor and didn't significantly impact the overall driving experience. For instance, one model might offer a premium sound system as standard equipment, while it's an optional extra on another. Similarly, there might be variations in the availability of certain safety features or driver-assistance technologies.
• Marketing and Target Audience: Subaru and Toyota targeted slightly different demographics with their respective versions of the car. Subaru aimed for a more mature and sophisticated audience, emphasizing the car's handling and performance capabilities. Toyota, on the other hand, targeted a younger and more style-conscious audience, highlighting the car's sporty design and affordability. This difference in marketing strategy influenced the styling and feature choices for each model.

It's important to note that the specific differences between the models can vary depending on the model year. As the cars evolved over time, both Subaru and Toyota made updates and changes to their respective versions. Therefore, it's always a good idea to compare the specific features and specifications of the models you're interested in before making a decision.

Performance and Handling: A Driver's Delight

No matter which badge it wears, the BRZ/FR-S/GT86 delivers an exceptional driving experience. These cars are all about balance, responsiveness, and driver engagement. The lightweight chassis, combined with the low center of gravity and well-tuned suspension, results in incredibly nimble handling. The cars feel planted and confident in corners, allowing drivers to push their limits without feeling like they're going to lose control. The steering is precise and communicative, providing excellent feedback and making it easy to place the car exactly where you want it on the road.

The 2.0-liter boxer engine, while not the most powerful, is a joy to rev. It delivers a linear and predictable powerband, making it easy to modulate the throttle and maintain control. The engine's responsiveness and willingness to rev encourage drivers to explore the upper reaches of the RPM range, adding to the overall driving excitement. The manual transmission, with its short throws and precise feel, is the perfect complement to the engine's character. It provides a direct and involving connection between the driver and the car, making every shift a satisfying experience.

One of the defining characteristics of these cars is their tail-happy nature. The rear-wheel-drive layout and relatively low power output make it easy to induce controlled oversteer, allowing drivers to drift the car through corners. This can be incredibly fun and rewarding, but it also requires a certain level of skill and experience. For those who are new to rear-wheel-drive cars, it's important to practice in a safe and controlled environment before attempting to drift on public roads.

While the BRZ/FR-S/GT86 excels on twisty roads and racetracks, it's also a surprisingly comfortable and practical daily driver. The suspension is firm but not harsh, and the seats are supportive and comfortable, even on long journeys. The interior is well-designed and functional, with all the essential controls within easy reach. The trunk is surprisingly spacious for a sports car, and the rear seats can be folded down to create even more cargo space.

Choosing Your Champion: Which One is Right for You?

So, after all this, which of the BRZ, FR-S, or GT86 should you choose? Honestly, it often comes down to personal preference, availability, and price. Since they're mechanically identical, the driving experience will be virtually the same regardless of which one you pick. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:

• Styling Preference: Do you prefer the more understated and refined look of the BRZ, or the more aggressive and sporty appearance of the FR-S/GT86? Let your personal taste guide you.
• Availability and Price: Check your local market for availability and pricing. Sometimes, one model might be more readily available or offer a better deal than the others.
• Brand Loyalty: Are you a Subaru enthusiast or a Toyota fan? Your brand preference might influence your decision.
• Features and Options: Compare the features and options available on each model to see which one best suits your needs and budget.

Ultimately, the best way to decide is to test drive each model and see which one you connect with the most. Get behind the wheel, feel the handling, and listen to the engine. You'll quickly discover which one feels right for you. No matter which you choose, you're guaranteed to have a blast!

The Second Generation: A New Era

It's important to note that a second generation of the BRZ and 86 (now officially named the GR86) has been released. These models feature significant updates, including a more powerful 2.4-liter engine, improved handling, and updated styling. While the core concept remains the same, the second-generation cars offer a noticeable improvement in performance and overall refinement. If you're considering buying a new sports car, it's definitely worth checking out the latest models.

The new 2.4-liter engine addresses one of the main criticisms of the original cars: the lack of low-end torque. The larger engine provides a significant boost in power and torque throughout the rev range, making the cars feel much more responsive and eager to accelerate. The improved handling is a result of a stiffer chassis, retuned suspension, and wider tires. These upgrades result in even more precise and predictable handling, making the cars even more fun to drive on twisty roads.

The styling of the second-generation cars is also more modern and aggressive, with sharper lines and a more sculpted appearance. The interior has been updated as well, with a more driver-focused design and improved materials.

Whether you choose a first-generation BRZ/FR-S/GT86 or a second-generation BRZ/GR86, you're sure to enjoy a thrilling and engaging driving experience. These cars are all about fun, affordability, and driver involvement. They're the perfect choice for anyone who loves to drive and appreciates the joy of a well-balanced sports car.

Conclusion: A Legacy of Affordable Fun

The BRZ, FR-S, and GT86 have carved a special place in the hearts of car enthusiasts. They represent a return to the basics: a lightweight, rear-wheel-drive sports car that prioritizes handling and driver engagement over outright power. Whether you're a seasoned racer or a casual driver, these cars offer a unique and rewarding driving experience that's hard to find elsewhere. With their affordable price point and readily available aftermarket support, they're also a great platform for customization and personalization. So, get out there, take a test drive, and experience the magic for yourself! You won't be disappointed.